IPI International Potash Institute
IPI International Potash Institute

Research Findings: e-ifc No. 23, June 2010

Potassium Balances and Long-Term Sustainability of Sorghum-Wheat in an Alluvial Soil of Haryana, India

Singh K., and S.K. Bansal(1)
print version pdf download pdf 684 kB

(1)Potash Research Institute of India (PRII); Sector-19, Gurgaon 122001 (Haryana) India. surinkumar@yahoo.co.in.

Introduction
Potassium exists in four forms in soil: water soluble, exchangeable, non-exchangeable, and structural or mineral form. Equilibrium and kinetic reactions between these four forms of soil K determine the contribution of each soil K form in supplying growing crop plants via K from soil solution (Sparks and Huang, 1985). In alluvial soils in which mica is found as a dominant mineral, a substantial quantity of K is released from the mineral structure which provides most of the K taken up (Singh et al., 2007). This release of K, however, is probably inadequate to sustain long-term crop cultivation and there is a need to investigate the contribution that it provides. A longterm field study was therefore carried out growing sorghum and wheat supplied with different levels of K fertilizer (and N and P) on an illite dominant Inceptisol soil of Southern Haryana. This experiment had three objectives: i) to quantify long-term K contribution of each soil K form to growing sorghum and wheat; ii) to quantify long-term K release from the structural form; and iii) to assess the effect of K release from structural soil K on long-term sustainability of growing sorghum and wheat.

Project location in India
Project location in India.

Materials and Methods
A potassium balance sheet was drawn up using inputs including fertilizers, farmyard manure and irrigation water, and output through crop offtakes and soil K status in different treatments after 20 crop cycles in a long-term experiment which was started in 1985 on a loamy sand Udic Haplustept at the Potash Research Institute of India (PRII), Gurgaon, Haryana, India, involving a sorghum (fodder)-wheat cropping system. Both crops were irrigated occasionally to compensate for lack of precipitation.

Soil
The major feature of this experiment was the K status of the soil on which the long-term field experiment was carried out, an illite dominated Inceptisol containing substantial amounts of K in mineral form. The initial chemical and physical characteristics of this soil, as well as the irrigation water used in 1985, are given in Table 1.

     
  Table 1. Initial (1985) properties of the Udic Haplustept long-term experiment and average (140 irrigations) chemical composition of ground water used to irrigate sorghum and wheat in 20 crop cycles.  
  Parameter Unit Value  
  Soil (0-15 cm)      
  pH (1:2)   8.2  
  EC (1:2) dSm-1 0.19  
  Organic Carbon (mg kg-1) 2.37  
  CEC (cmol(p+)kg-1) 4.20  
  Sand % 79.6  
  Silt % 9.4  
  Clay % 11.0  
  Texture   Loamy-sand  
  Classification   Udic Haplustept  
  Bulk Density (Mg m-3) 1.48  
  Saturated Hydraulic-Conductivity (cm h-1) 4.5  
  Alkaline KMnO4 - N (mg kg-1) 63.5  
  Olsen P (mg kg-1) 2.4  
  1N NH4OAc-K (mg kg-1) 75.1  
  Non - exchangeable K (mg kg-1) 773  
         
  Water      
  pH   7.65  
  EC (dSm-1) 1.15  
  Ca+Mg (meq l-1) 5.50  
  Na+ (meq l-1) 5.58  
  K+ (mg l-1) 3.90  
  CO3-2 (meq l-1) ND  
  HCO3- (meq l-1) 6.4  
  SO4-2 (meq l-1) ND  
  Cl- (meq l-1) 4.9  
  NO3 - (mg l-1) 22.5  
  SAR (meq l-1)0.5 3.37  
  RSC (meq l-1) 0.9  
         

The soil with almost 80 percent sand, and about 10 percent silt and clay developed on alluvial parent material. Mica was present in all three fractions and was also the dominant mineral in the silt fraction in which K feldspars were present as an associate mineral. The clay fraction consisted of 40 percent illite, 15 percent vermiculite, 25 percent chlorite, 14.5 percent kaolinite, 5 percent amorphous material and 10 percent feldspar + quartz (Sekhon et al., 1992). The pH of the soil was slightly alkaline and had a normal value of electrical conductivity. The soil for this longterm experiment was medium in both 1N NH4OAC (water soluble and exchangeable K) and boiling 1N HNO3 K (non-exchangeable K) in 1985, and had low organic carbon status (Table 1), but the soils of the area were considered to be a good supplier of K to growing crops. NH4OAC-K, which includes water soluble and exchangeable K, was determined according to Hanway and Heidel (1952).

Long-Term field experiment
In the field experiment there were seven treatment combinations with three levels of N (0, 120 and 240 kg ha-1 crop-1), two levels of P (26.2 and 52.3 kg ha-1 crop-1) and three levels of K (0, 49.8 and 99.6 kg ha-1 crop-1). Each treatment was given to both wheat (in winter) and sorghum (in summer) (Table 2). These treatments were replicated three times in a randomized block design. Three levels of K (0, 49.8 and 98.8 kg ha-1 crop-1) were applied along with the optimum recommended doses of 120 kg N and 26.2 kg P, two levels of K (0 and 99.6 kg K ha-1) were applied at high doses of 240 kg N and 52.3 kg P. The doses of 120 kg N, 26.2 kg P and 49.8 kg K were integrated with 10 tonnes farmyard manure. The farmyard manure used in this experiment contained 0.5 percent K, equivalent to 50 kg K ha-1 year-1 in each wheat and sorghum.

     
  Table 2. Treatments of the long-term fertilizer experiment, 1985-2005.  
  Treatment Nutrient level  
    kg ha-1  
  Control 0  
  N1P1K0 120-26.2-0  
  N2P2K0 240-52.3-0  
  N1P1K1 120-26.2-49.8  
  N1P1K2 120-26.2-99.6  
  N2P2K2 240-52.3-99.6  
  N1P1K1+FYM 120-26.2-49.8+10 mt FYM  
  Note: P and K are represented in their elemental forms.  
     

During the period of 20 crop cycles, the sorghum was sown in the last week of June and harvested in the first week of September as a fodder crop, while wheat was sown in mid November and harvested in the second week of April. The full dose of P and K with half of the dose of N was applied at sowing time, and the remaining half dose of N was applied after the first irrigation in both crops. A uniform dose of 10 kg Zn ha-1 year-1 was also applied in the form of zinc sulfate heptahydrate. The sources of N, P and K were urea, di-ammonium phosphate (DAP) and potassium chloride (MOP), respectively.

During the 20 crop cycles, 140 irrigations - each having 7.5 cm depth - was applied using underground water. The average (of 140 irrigations) chemical composition of underground water used in irrigation is given in Table 1. Total K contribution from underground water was computed by multiplying the amount of water applied by the average K concentration of water applied in 20 crop cycles.

Harvested plant samples were weighed then oven-dried at 70°C to constant weight and ground to a fine powder. Measurement of K was carried out by the standard method of flame photometry following acid digestion (HCl-HNO3).

Total K offtake by wheat and sorghum in 20 crop cycles was calculated by multiplying the K content in fodder for sorghum and grain and straw for wheat by their respective yields. K contribution from different forms of soil K was assessed by taking into account the changes in 1N NH4OAC-K, and nonexchangeable K in 20 crop cycles. K released from the structural form of soil K was calculated using the following formula:

tKr = t K off - depinsoil + bupinsoil - K added

tKr = total K released in 20 crop cycles from the structural form of soil K (kg K ha-1); tK off = total K removed by wheat and sorghum in 20 cycles (kg K ha-1); depinsoil = net depletion in NH4OAC and non-exchangeable K status of soil in 20 cycles (kg K ha-1); bupinsoil = net build up in NH4OAC and nonexchangeable K status of soil in 20 cycles (kg K ha-1); K added = total amount of K added in 20 cycles through fertilizer, manure and from irrigation water (kg K ha-1). Leaching and deposition of K were neither measured nor calculated in this experiment.

Fig 1. Cumulative grain yields of wheat and DM of sorghum over 20 years (1985-2005).
Fig 1. Cumulative grain yields of wheat and DM of sorghum over 20 years (1985-2005).
click to enlarge

Results and Discussion
Wheat yields
Cumulative wheat grain yield over the 20 years presents a different picture from sorghum (Fig. 1). Cumulative wheat grain yield in the control was only 18.1 mt ha-1 which increased five fold to 94.9 mt ha-1 by NP application with N120P26.2K0. Application of 49.8 kg ha-1 crop-1 year-1 in N1P1K1 produced a cumulative wheat grain yield of 103.1 mt ha-1 which works out to be a response of about 9 percent for the K applied. Applying a higher dose of K (99.6 kg K ha-1 year-1) with N120P26.2 did not show any benefit as the cumulative grain yield was only 102 mt ha-1. However, applying 10 mt FYM with the N120P26.2K49.6 treatment produced a cumulative grain yield of 109.2 mt ha-1 which was on a par with that of the N240P52.3K99.6 treatment (109.8 mt ha-1), showing the greater advantage of FYM application for the grain crop of wheat as compared to that of the fodder crop of sorghum. Application of the N240P52.3K99.6 treatment produced 109.8 mt ha-1 of cumulative wheat grain yield which was about 12.8 percent more than for the N240P52.3K0 treatment (97.3 mt ha-1).

Sorghum yields
Cumulative crop yields of sorghum (fodder) dry matter (DM) and wheat grain over the 20 crop cycles are shown in Fig. 1. Cumulative sorghum DM yield in the control (N0P0K0) was 40.7 mt ha-1, which rose to 130.1 mt ha-1 in the N120P26.2K0 treatment and increased further by about 12 percent to 156.7 mt ha-1 by the additional application of 49.8 kg K ha-1 crop-1 year-1 (treatment N120P26.2K49.8). Doubling the application of N and P, but without K, (N240P52.3K0) reduced the sorghum DM yield to 125.4 mt ha-1. The highest cumulative yield of 196 mt ha-1 was obtained by doubling the application of K to 98.6 kg K ha-1 crop-1 year-1 together with the doubled N and P (N240P52.3K99.6). This led to an increase of about 56.8 percent in DM yield over that without K, (N240P52.3K0). The treatment with 10 mt FYM associated with low levels of N, P, and K application in the form of mineral fertilizers did not compensate for the lower amount of mineral fertilizer nutrients applied and DM yields were correspondingly lower than in the N240P52.3K99.6 treatment.

Application of FYM differs in its effect on wheat grain yield and dry matter yield of vegetative sorghum. For wheat application of FYM, together with relatively low levels of NPK (N120P26.2K49.8), may be sufficient for sustainable production, whereas for high sorghum fodder yields, it is essential to apply twice as much mineral fertilizer as N, P and K, (N240P52.3K99.6), with the benefit of additional FYM seen only at the lower mineral fertilizer application rate (N120P26.2 K49.8).

Potassium offtake for wheat
Potassium offtake in the various treatments varied greatly and for the whole cropping system (including sorghum and wheat) increased almost four-fold as compared to the control (Table 3). For wheat, potassium offtake tripled after fertilizing with N and P (N120P26.2K0) as compared to the control, demonstrating the effect of increased K offtake just by applying N and P. The magnitude of increase in offtake by grain and straw was similar: K offtake by grain increased from 107 to 484, and that of straw from 536 to 1497 kg K ha-1. Adding K fertilizer (N120P26.2K49.8) significantly increased K offtake, mostly in the straw. Highest K offtake in wheat was in the treatment that achieved the highest yield with high K (N240P52.3K98.6) at 3,684 kg K offtake over 20 years.

     
  Table 3. Offtake of K by wheat and sorghum in 20 crop cycles.  
  Treatments
kg ha-1 crop-1
Wheat Sorghum Total  
  Grain Straw Total      
    kg ha-1  
  N0P0K0 107 536 643 947 1590  
  N120P26.2K0 484 1,497 1,981 1,131 3,112  
  N240P52.3K0 497 1,154 1,651 632 2,283  
  N120P26.2K49.8 557 2,352 2,909 1,546 4,455  
  N120P26.2K99.6 561 2,835 3,396 2,592 5,988  
  N240P52.3K99.6 585 3,099 3,684 2,047 5,731  
  N120P26.2K49.8
+10 mt FYM
568 2,818 3,386 2,177 5,563  
  C.D (P≤0.05) 55 154   145    
               

Potassium offtake for sorghum
Similar to wheat, application of N and P (compared with the control) increased yields and hence also K offtake but at a much lower magnitude (2.5 fold). Highest K offtake by sorghum was at N120P26.2K99.6. However, this treatment was not the best in terms of DM production.

Potassium status in soil
Increase in the exchangeable potassium was evident only with the high K applications (K99.6) in both horizons or with FYM for the A horizon (A – 0-15 cm and B – 15-30 cm; Table 4). In general, exchangeable K in the upper horizons (0-15 cm) were depressed more than the 15-30 cm, whilst changes in exchangeable K were from -94 to +51 kg ha-1 during the period 1985- 2005.

Table 4. Changes in 1N NH4OAC-K (water soluble plus exchangeable K) and non-exchangeable K status of the Udic Haplustept over 20 crop cycles.
Table 4. Changes in 1N NH4OAC-K (water soluble plus exchangeable K) and non-exchangeable K status of the Udic Haplustept over 20 crop cycles.
click to enlarge

Non-exchangeable K showed depletion of K in the A horizon (0-15 cm) but build up of K in the B horizon, yet, the total calculation for the 0-30 cm showed decline in non-exchangeable K in most of the treatments (Table 4). Non-exchangeable form of soil K is held between adjacent tetrahedral layers of dioctahedral and trioctahedral mica, and is only moderately to sparingly available to crop plants (Sparks and Huang 1987). In 20 cycles, this form of soil K contributed 6.62 percent K to the total K removed by sorghum and wheat, which were grown with the recommended doses of N and P (N120P26.2K0) (Table 3 and Fig. 2). This K contribution was attributed to net 206 kg K ha-1 decrease in value of this form, both at surface and subsurface layers of plots receiving the treatment N120P26.2K0 (Table 4).

Negative changes in exchangeable and non exchangeable K in soil occurred in conjunction with low yields and K offtake (Fig. 1 and Fig. 2) which were with the zero K treatments. Application of K in any of the treatments dramatically changes the soil K balance (Fig. 2).

Fig 2. Change in exchangeable and non-exchangeable K and K offtake during 1985-2005.
Fig 2. Change in exchangeable and non-exchangeable K and K offtake during 1985-2005.
click to enlarge

The above findings show that K released from the structural form was unable to sustain sorghum and wheat productivity at optimum levels. Consequently, both sorghum and wheat responded significantly to applied K fertilizer; sorghum responding to a greater extent in comparison to wheat (Fig. 1). Sorghum, owing to its shallow root system, only absorbs K from the surface layers of the soil, whereas wheat, on the other hand, absorbs K from the surface and subsurface layers due to its deep root system. For this reason, greater responses to applied K fertilizer were found in sorghum rather than wheat.

Exchangeable K forms of soil, contributed 3 percent K, and nonexchangeable K form contributed 6.6 percent K to the total K removed by sorghum and wheat over 20 crop cycles. Ground water used in irrigations contributed 13.1 percent K. The contribution of soil K forms to growing sorghum and wheat including the K release from the structural form, decreased significantly with the K fertilizer application to the growing crops.

Fig 3. Total inputs and outputs of K in wheat-sorghum cropping system during 1985-2005.
Fig 3. Total inputs and outputs of K in wheat-sorghum cropping system during 1985-2005.
click to enlarge

Potassium balance
Our results show that the structural K form or lattice K form, which is found in K feldspars, mica and in other K bearing minerals, released a substantial amount of K which contributed most of the K required during 20 growing cycles of sorghum and wheat. Overall, however, this release still fell short in meeting the entire crop K needs. In plots receiving the treatment N120P26.2K0, as much as 2,404 kg K ha-1 was released from the structural form of soil K which contributed 77.25 percent K to the total K removed by growing sorghum and wheat over 20 cycles (Table 5 and Fig. 3). Similarly in plots in which sorghum and wheat was grown with the treatment N240P52.3K0, 1,457 kg K ha-1 was released from this form which contributed 63.8 percent K.

     
  Table 5. Balance of K between the various sources (1985-2005).  
    Output
of K(1)
Inputs of K by sources(1)
(depinsoil + bupinsoil)
Net depletion of
soil K from
structural K(2)
(tKr)
 
  Treatments Total K
offtake
by the
crops
Irrigation
water
Fertilizer Soil water
soluble &
exchangeable
K
Soil non-exchangeable
K
 
  kg ha-1 crop-1 kg ha-1  
  N0P0K0 1590 409 0 36 81 1064  
  N120P26.2K0 3112 409 0 93 206 2404  
  N240P52.3K0 2283 409 0 94 323 1457  
  N120P26.2K49.8 4455 409 1992 45 0 2034  
  N120P26.2K98.6 5988 409 3984 0 0 1948  
  N240P52.3K98.6 5731 409 3984 0 43 1307  
  N120P26.2K49.8 +10 mt FYM 5563 409 3992 16 0 1189  
  (1)Analyzed; (2)Calculated  
     

The rate of K release from the structural form decreased significantly with K fertilizer application, consequently, K contribution of this form decreased (Table 5). The most important factor that controls the rate of K release from the structural form is the concentration of K in soil solution. The higher the K concentration in soil solution, the lower the K release from the structural form. Hence, the greater K in soil solution for the K fertilized plots (Table 5) in this long-term experiment must have decreased the release of structural K.

Conclusion
It is concluded that despite substantial K release from the structural form in an Udic Haplustept which contributed 77.3 percent K of the total K removed by sorghum and wheat in a long-term experiment (20 crop cycles), K fertilizer is still needed to maintain K fertility and sustain yields in the cultivation of these crops on this loamy sand soil rich in illite.

These findings refute the general myth that illite dominant alluvial soils of north-western India contain soil reserves of K sufficient to sustain K supply to growing crops over longperiods without any K fertilization. Another, belief that the amount of K in irrigation water in the area is enough to sustain the K requirements of growing crops has also been shown to be wrong.

This long-term study conclusively proved that sufficient K fertilization (at 49.8 kg K ha-1 crop-1) to each crop is needed to sustain optimum crop productivity despite the high contributions from the structural K form. This study also proved that application of high doses of N and P without K (which is a general practice in the area) could be detrimental to both soil and crop productivity on a long-term basis. Exchangeable and soluble forms of soil K contributed least K to growing sorghum and wheat. The K contribution of non-exchangeable form was found to be much less than that of the structural form of soil K.

References

  • Hanway, J.J., and H. Heidel. 1952. Soil analysis methods as used in Iowa State College, Soil Testing Laboratory. Iowa Agriculture, 27:1-13.
  • Sekhon, G.S., M.S. Brar, and A. Subba Rao. 1992. Potassium in Some Benchmark Soils of India. PRII, Gurgaon, India.
  • Singh, K., S.K. Bansal, and Mouinuddin. 2007. Effect of continuous cropping for twenty years on some properties of the intensively cultivated alluvial soils and nutrient indexing of rice. J. Indian Soc. Soil. Sc. 55:265-269.
  • Sparks, D.L., and P.M. Huang. 1985. Physical Chemistry of soil potassium. In: Munson, R. D (ed.) Potassium in Agriculture.

 

The Rothamsted Long-Term Experiments: Are They Still of Use?

Jenkinson, D.S. AFRC Inst. of Arable Crops Res. Rothamsted Exp. Stn., Harpenden, Herts AL5 2JQ, England. Agron J 83:2-10. 1991.

The Rothamsted long-term experiments-the Classicals-were started almost 150 yr ago. These experiments were originally designed to study the N, P, K, Na, Mg, and Si needs of the field crops then grown in England. This was done by comparing these inorganic nutrients, in various combinations, with farmyard manure, the traditional source of fertility at that time. Although the questions the experiments were originally designed to answer have long been re-solved, the experiments continue to give results of interest to agron omists, ecologists, soil scientists, plant pathologists, and others. The experiments show that grain yields can be sustained (and even increased) for almost 150 years in monocultures of wheat and barley given organic or inorganic fertilizer annually. They provide data on the long-term effects of inorganic fertilizers and organic manures on soil organic matter levels. These data have been used to test computer-based models for the turnover of organic matter in soil. Again, long-term N balances show that there are considerable inputs of N to the soil/plant system, amounting to some 30 kg N ha-1 yr-1 in unfertilized wheat and up to 65 kg ha-1 yr-1 in an arable soil reverting to woodland. These and other results are used to consider the advantages and disadvantages of long-term experiments. Wisely used, long-term experimental sites provide information on the long-term sustainability of agricultural systems that can be obtained in no other way.

 

 

The paper "Potassium Balances and Long-Term Sustainability of Sorghum-Wheat in an Alluvial Soil of Haryana, India" is also available in: Regional Activities/India